International Greetings is unexpected present
Synergise to maximise
It’s surprising how much money there is in the most prosaic things. Take the manufacture of gift wrap, a product we use a few times a year and discard almost immediately.
Last year, hardly a vintage year but one in which the company showed early signs of recovering from a near-death experience, International Greetings (IGR) sold 1.5 billion feet of gift wrap worth £74.6m or about 37% of total sales.
Fifty-four per-cent of sales, which also include stationery, greetings cards, Christmas crackers, and bags, come from the UK, but maybe not for long.
International Greetings’ recovery plan involves reducing its dependence on the UK, Christmas, gift wrap, department stores, and unbranded products manufactured for retailers. Its own brands and licensed brands like Disney and The Simpsons have increased their share of turnover from 41% last year to 54% this year.
There was more to the catastrophic collapse in confidence in International Greetings than over-dependence on the UK market, or Christmas, which still happened in 2008.
![]()
Indeed its ambition to expand was part of the problem. As it integrated companies it had bought at home and abroad, and relocated manufacturing to China, debt and costs increased.
Then revenues fell as the economy worsened and International Greetings, a stock market darling in the previous decade, was loss-making.
We can see the internal and external turmoil in the commentary on the previous year’s exceptional items, significant profits and losses that it does not normally experience.
Debtors (like Woolworths) that went bust, redundancies, restructuring costs, and reductions in the accounting value of machinery it no longer needed, and a business, Glitterwrap, it paid too much for in 2007, cost the company over £21m.
Like a teenager looking for dirty words in a dictionary, the company has dredged its lexicon to find the very worst corporate-speak in which to express its new mantra: "Synergise to Maximise". Although I shudder at the language, by closing superfluous factories, withdrawing from loss-making business and knitting together the operations of its many brands, it seems to be reducing costs and returning to profitability.
Despite an 8% fall in sales, International Greetings was profitable in the year ending 31 March 2010, it had reduced debt and has scaled back its ambitions.
Its directors won’t pay a dividend, though, until they are sure that the profit trend is sustained, and the company has repaid more debt.
Although Anders Hedlund, the founder, former chief executive, deputy chairman and, presumably one of the principle architects of the company’s rise and fall, still controls IGR, owning more than 45% of the shares, the new ceo, Paul Fineman, is a relatively new face. He got the job in January 2009 having joined as managing director of Anker International, one of International Greeting’s acquisitions. Financial Director Sheryl Tye joined in February 2008.
Tye bought 16,000 shares last month for 62p, the same price they are now, and I’m not surprised. International Greetings is dirt cheap costing just four times earnings averaged over the last 10 years, and it appears to be recovering.
More conservative investors would wait for the dividend to confirm the company is off life-support, but I rely on the F_Score to anticipate a return to health, and buy the shares, hopefully, at a lower price. International Greetings has a healthy F_Score of 7 out of 9
As usual, I’m torn between the desire to buy value when I see it, and the need to conserve cash in case the markets crash and present an opportunity to buy really good companies at bargain prices.
Maybe I’ll be raising some cash soon, though. Games Workshop and XP Power are both more than 50% higher than the price they were when they joined the portfolio, a trigger point at which I re-evaluate a share’s suitability.
Unexpectedly, I’ve added International Greetings to the portfolio. It’s a classic Thrifty 30 company. Let’s hope it synergises to the max, or cuts costs and boost profits, anyway.
-
Thrifty 30 updates
The current Thrifty 30 portfolio
Triumphal results from power adapter manufacturer XP Power, shame I jumped aboard this one so late
Titon, which makes bits ‘n pieces for windows ‘n doors, is growing sales and cash according to an interim management statement.
Auto engineer Ricardo reports the auto industry is recovering, a relief because it is one of four Thrifty 30 companies in the sector.
Mixed results from electronics distributor Solid State. Sales up, profits down.
Profitability is rising at fantasy model manufacturer Games Workshop, still waiting for sales growth, though.
Go figure. Surveillance supplier Quadnetics is reporting 12 month interims. Profit is on the up.
Austerity hit school supplier RM when the govt cancelled BSF. RM says schools will still spend.
6 Comments
Leave a comment
Comments
- Richard Beddard on Learning from Lauren
- Mark Carter on Learning from Lauren
- Richard Beddard on Ambivalent about French correction
- Mark Carter on Ambivalent about French correction
- Ken Kahura on Towards the perfect PE
- Richard Beddard on Games Workshop in two minutes
- Ethereal on Games Workshop in two minutes
- Monevator on Throwing the net wide open
- Richard Beddard on Throwing the net wide open
- Monevator on Throwing the net wide open
- Richard Beddard on Throwing the net wide open
- Monevator on Throwing the net wide open
- The cyclically-adjusted P/E ratio (PE10 or Shiller PE) on State of the market
- Philip O'Sullivan on Churchill China in 1 minute 53 seconds
- Richard Beddard on Churchill China in 1 minute 53 seconds
- Market Musings 1/5/2012 « Philip O'Sullivan's Market Musings on Churchill China in 1 minute 53 seconds
- Philip O'Sullivan on Churchill China in 1 minute 53 seconds
- Brad on Million Dollar Traders
- Stefan | Simple Value Investing on Pensions: peril or profit?
- Richard Beddard on PV Crystalox Solar in 1 minute 56 seconds
RB on Twitter
- @pdosullivan Thanks Philip. Ditto.
- Interesting thoughts from @mcturra2000 on magic formula investing http://t.co/JEq0Ak1j my reply: http://t.co/UHRnYZKR
- Just discovered there are two Mervyn Kings. This one hits the bullseye https://t.co/JmPZPIIp This one moves the target https://t.co/JmPZPIIp
- @smarkus Thanks
- Thinking of tackling Next L:NXT next. It scares me witless. @spbaines and @GeoffGannon wld have me rely on earning power. Soooo hard...
Latest posts
- French Connection in 2 minutes 9 seconds
- Restoration man
- Redefining French Connection
- Leases key to retailer’s financial position
- Ambivalent about French correction
- Three earnings yields
- Premier Foods in 2 minutes 11 seconds
- Throwing the net wide open
- Holders Technology in 2 minutes 8 seconds
- Churchill China in 1 minute 53 seconds
Sections
Companies
Archives
Blogroll
- Alphaville
- Barel Karsan
- Eurosharelab
- Expecting Value
- Gannon on Investing
- Mark Carter
- Monevator
- Musings on Markets
- My Investing Notebook
- Neonomic
- Oddball Stocks
- Peston's Picks
- Philip O'Sullivan
- Seth's Posterous
- The Value Perspective
- Turnkey Analyst
- UK Value Investor
- Value Stock Inquisition
- Valuhunteruk.com
- Wexboy



Hi Richard,
I am also chasing net working cap stocks but they are very hard to come by these days. Only the usual suspects are still around, nothing new. I’m slowly upping my search criteria to include those stocks whose value is less than book value ( with almost no debt of course ). Let’s hope for a large market crash to bring those prices down. :O)
Keep up the good work on the blog. I enjoy reading it.
Marcel
Hi Marcel,
Thanks for taking the trouble to leave a comment. You might also like UK Value Investor’s blog. He too likes to buy below (tangible) book value: http://www.ukvalueinvestor.com/
My own answer to the conundrum of what to look for when there aren’t many absolute bargains around is to look for highly profitable companies that are cheap. Basically I prefer net-nets and what I call Thrifty 30 companies (very cheap in relation to long-term average earnings), but also consider companies with relatively high return on capital that look cheap (along the lines of Greenblatt’s Magic Formula). I work down these lists: http://blog.iii.co.uk/thrifty-30-candidates/
I also prefer to keep more of the Thrifty 30 portfolio in cash if I think shares are expensive, as you say, in case the market takes a tumble. See: http://blog.iii.co.uk/2010-an-investing-odyssey/
Good luck with the investing. Let me know how it goes!
Richard.
[...] don’t think I made the wrong decision, even though history shows International Greetings, the company I switched to, has not yet made the Thrifty 30 much [...]
Hello Richard,
The annual accounts of International Greetings seem to be overdue.
The last trading update stated that they would be released early July!
Anything significant in this?
Regards
John
Hi John, how curious, you’re right the results were due in early July according to the trading update in May, and since then nothing.
I’ve just called the FD who told me there’s not much she can say because they’re in a closed period but they’re waiting to sign off legal agreements relating to refinancing and there’s “nothing to worry about”. They should be in a position to release the results “any day now”.
This is a new one for me, so I can’t really comment on the significance. I’m working on the assumption that if there were a significant problem they’d have to make an announcement via the stock exchange.
Thanks for your quick response Richard.
When I spoke to the office of the Company Secretary, they said that they could not put a date on the release of the annual accounts. When I pointed out that the AGM was to be held on the 4th August, they said that it would have to be postponed!
I smell trouble, so I have sold my 10,000 units.
It may be a storm in a tea-cup, but with a new Chairman to be appointed it does not look good.
Regards
John